Final Rating:
Date of Completion: 17/03/2023
Published by: Recorded Books
ISBN: B07XH7ZRDN
Cover:
This design pulled me in with its gothic font and fierce illustration of Gideon. However, the story is not as gritty or action-packed as the cover suggests.
Writing:
The descriptive writing style is made even more engaging through a quirky and witty third-person narrative from Gideon’s point of view. Not only was the sarcastic, easygoing humour so entertaining that I was constantly laughing, but it also made Gideon’s character relatable and easy to like. While I also loved the captivating world, I craved a deeper exploration of the Houses and magic system.
Anyone can learn to fight. Hardly anyone learns to think.
Storyline:
Rife with tension, reveals, and action, the start and climax of this story were highly compelling. Sadly, I was bored by the rest of the story as the pace was slow, and I failed to fully understand the unfolding trials and mystery.
Main character:
I quickly fell in love with Gideon as her character was full of sass and self-assured. These personality traits made her realistic and easy to connect with, despite only experiencing little growth in the story. I also enjoyed the contrast between the mystical atmosphere of the story and Gideon’s casual and modern speech.
Why was I born so attractive?… Because everyone would have throttled you within the first five minutes otherwise
Secondary characters:
With most secondary characters introduced around the same point in the story, I found it hard to differentiate them. These characters are also given little complexity and development – except for Harrowhark, who won me over with her craftiness and gradual vulnerability.
Romance:
Gideon’s infatuation with a certain necromancer from another House was very cute and endearing, even though it only had a slight role in the story. (But I lowkey wanted Gideon with Harrowhark, despite their constant bickering and suspicion of each other.)
Narration & Audio:
Moira Quirk skillfully alters her voice and rhythm to create an entertaining listening experience that enhances the story. I especially loved the different tones and accents for the characters, as this helped somewhat with distinguishing them.
With its fascinating world and protagonist, ‘Gideon the Ninth’ gets off to a strong start, but the story soon loses its appeal. I struggled through most of the story, with only the occasional moment of action and humorous narrative keeping me engaged before things picked up again in the climax. I am reminded of Godkiller by Hannah Kaner, which also possesses an entertaining mix of fantasy and action, plus great characters. Why not check that out if you loved this story.
Do you agree or disagree with anything mentioned above? Let us know in the comments below.
To read other book related posts, click here or check out the tag cloud for more options.