Final Rating:
Date of Completion: 28/03/2025
Published by: Penguin
ISBN: 9781804951200
‘Blood Over Bright Haven’ raises fascinating moral dilemmas and social commentaries, making it a powerful and memorable read.
Cover:
Writing:
Storyline:
Main character(s):
Secondary characters:
Romance:
Narration & Audio:
What struck me first was the vivid similes and rich writing style that brought this story to life. The world-building was also impressive, packed with intricate history, politics, and magic. However, some aspects went over my head, and the information is mainly presented in chunks at the start of the story. Still, the elaborate world allowed for complex themes such as misogyny, systemic oppression, prejudice, power and legacy to be deeply explored and provided a solid foundation for thought-provoking social commentaries. These compelling themes were the best part of the novel for me.
Truth over delusion. Growth over comfort.
The storyline kicks off with an intriguing and intense start that provides essential context before Sciona’s journey unfolds. I enjoyed the twists and turns of the story, even though the biggest reveal was pretty easy to predict. The dark academia vibe is also brilliantly executed, offering a twisted backdrop of fierce rivalries, nepotism and sabotage. As the story builds toward its climax, tension mounts, and the realistic consequences of Sciona’s choices made it all the more memorable.
Sciona herself is a remarkably complex and flawed antihero. She is self-absorbed, ambitious, power-hungry, yet also strangely naive. Her unyielding drive and struggle within a misogynistic society made it impossible not to root for her. Her ability to wrestle with conflicting viewpoints and relentless pursuit of truth also appealed to me, especially given how challenging it can be to confront personal biases and take a stand for a better society.
it’s much easier to tell yourself you’re a good person than it is to actually be one.
The secondary characters were far less memorable, and even Thomil didn’t leave a lasting impression. Sadly, this affected the light romance that unfurled, as I was not entirely convinced by the connection between the characters. In contrast, Moira Quirk’s narration was a standout. Quirk’s delivery nicely complemented the somewhat formal writing style and conveyed emotional range during the dialogue between characters.
Discussion Questions (Contains spoilers!):
Q: Which theme did you find the most interesting?
This book is filled with many powerful themes, but it was the exploration of systemic racism that stood out to me most. I appreciated how the complexities of oppression and privilege were portrayed. The story does not shy away from the crushing weariness that often weighs on those who are oppressed, along with the emotional and moral hurdles faced by those who benefit from the system. I also loved how the interplay between systemic racism and misogyny is highlighted, serving as a stark reminder of how these systems work to preserve the status quo.
Q: Have you ever gone for something that felt unattainable?
Yes! My biggest wins have come from taking risks that felt scary and sometimes unreachable. One example would be my massive career pivot, which felt terrifying and challenging to achieve, especially when I faced many rejections. Looking back, I am so grateful I pushed through all the uncertainty, as I now have a career I’m passionate about, a much better work-life balance, and immense support from my colleagues.
Q: How did you feel about how the story ended?
The ending didn’t leave me very satisfied, as the only hope provided was through the massacre of all those in power who perpetuated wrong. It was also sad that Sciona, who had taken a stand, never got to witness any real or lasting change. However, this seemed like an accurate representation of our world, as it is common for those who fight hard against wrong to not see the fruits of their labour. The fact that Thomil left Tiran was equally sad because this meant he would not be around to help bring about change.
Q: Do you have any similar recommendations?
The Fifth Season by N.K. Jemisin and The Jasmin Throne by Tasha Suri are similar epic fantasy reads that brilliantly explore themes like power, oppression and colonialism.
…
Q: Would you have handled the revelation of what Tiran’s magic involved any differently than Sciona?
Q: Have you ever taken a stand against wrong?
Q: Have you ever had a negative experience in the workplace?
Q: What are your thoughts on the arc given to Sciona’s mentor, Archmage Bringham?
Do you agree or disagree with anything mentioned above? Let us know in the comments below.
To read other book related posts, click here or check out the tag cloud for more options.
